Main Page

encyclopedia.codeboy.net

 

Poor design

The poor design argument opposes intelligent design by noting that the design of living beings is poor, and thus no higher intelligence could account for such a design. According to proponents of the view, poor design is evinced by the fragility of humans; humans must live in an environment with a very narrow temperature range (considering the extreme highs and lows in the natural world) and easily succumb to disease and degenerative processes. Some examples:
  • Sometimes a person's body produces too much estrogen or testosterone. That causes medical or psychological problems.
  • If knee-caps are such a good idea, why don't we have elbow-caps ?
  • The blind spot in the retina
  • Some creatures (such as starfish) can grow an entire limb back if it is cut off. Humans cannot.
  • Humans eventually grow old and die. This is often seen as the most serious limitation of the human body. Bacteria, yeast, and a few other creatures never grow old, and seem to have unlimited lifespans.

external links

http://freefall.purrsia.com/ff900/fv00807.htm

"God is a comedian playing to an audience too afraid to laugh." - Voltaire (1694-1778)